Animals, Mental Defectives, and the Social Contract
نویسنده
چکیده
Wbatever its merit as an account of political institutions, the social contract theory bas, in recent years, been the subject of intense scrutiny as an explanation for our moral obligations. Prominent examples of this approacb include the work of Jobn Rawls and David Gauthier. l A criticism of this understanding ofmoral obligation arises from several commentators, partly as a result of claims made by the original authors. The criticism is this: The social contract theory seems to imply that the scope of our moral obligations is unreasonably narrow. In particular, at fIrSt glance the theory seems to exclude from direct consideration the interests of animals and severely defective bumans. Criticisms of this sort are intuitive in nature and common to pbilosophy, yet many view them with disdain. It is an open question whether the failure of an otherwise attractive theoretical account to square with our moral intuitions tells against thetheory or the intuition, but resolving this dispute lies beyond the scope of this paper. However, surely the intuition and the theory cannot both be true, or at least this is bow it has seemed to the majority ofcommentators on the question. One either believes that we bave direct duties to animals
منابع مشابه
Extra-Institutional Care of Mental Defectives in New York State, U.S.A.
No State should consider itself either humane, or efficient from a business point of view, which continues to support in idleness any of its dependents (not excluding those physically or mentally handicapped), who might, under proper training and supervision, become at least partially self-supporting. But as a rule it is not until an intolerable weight of taxes drives a state into new methods o...
متن کاملبررسی بیماریهای پوستی در عقب ماندگان ذهنی مرکز شهید فیاض بخش همدان
Mental deficiency is not a disease in its own right but a condition resulting from a variety of causes, some inborn and others acquired. The skin abnormalities of mental defectives fall into three broad groups: 1. Cutaneous lesions specifically associated with syndromes of genetic or developmental origin. 2. Non-specific cutaneous lesions showing an increased prevalence in mental defectives. ...
متن کاملThe Work of Local Voluntary Associations and Possible Future Developments
almost directly after the Mental Deficiency Act came into force in 1914. One of their main objects was the co-ordination of all public and voluntary work undertaken for defectives in their own homes, throughout the area, covered by a Local Authority under the Mental Deficiency Act, i.e., a County or County Borough. The Constitution of these Associations varies according to Local conditions but ...
متن کاملThe Nursing of Mental Defectives
Mental Defectives, though it is a pity that the author did not include the legal definitions of mental deficiency as well as the modified explanatory ones.
متن کامل